When it comes to culinary delights, few cities rival the diverse and delectable offerings of New York City aka the Big Apple. Among its myriad food options, pizza stands out as a quintessential NYC experience, and one of the top Bucket List Experiences in the USA. Dive into a world of cheesy goodness and crispy crusts as we explore the best pizza restaurants in NYC, that should definitely find a place on your 7 Day New York City Travel Itinerary.

PS – Useful Travel Resources to use while heading to New York City to check out The Best Pizza Restaurants in NYC – 

10 of the Best Pizza Places in New York City

Lombardi’s Pizza 

Where Pizza History Lives

For those in search of a slice of pizza history, Lombardi’s in Nolita, Manhattan, is a must-visit. Established in 1905, Lombardi’s claims the title of the first pizzeria in the United States. The coal-oven pizzas, particularly the classic Margherita, are a testament to the restaurant’s enduring legacy as one of the top restaurants in New York City.

Joe’s Pizza

Greenwich Village Classic

In the heart of Greenwich Village, Joe’s Pizza has been satisfying cravings since 1975. As one of the best pizza places in NYC, Joe’s offers no-frills, delicious slices that embody the essence of classic New York-style pizza. It’s a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike seeking an authentic and satisfying pizza experience.


Brooklyn’s Brick-Oven Gem

For those venturing into Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn, Lucali beckons with its thin-crust, brick-oven pizzas. Renowned for its cozy atmosphere and BYOB policy, Lucali captures the essence of a neighbourhood pizzeria. The wait may be long, but the flavourful experience makes it well worth it.

Di Fara Pizza 

A Culinary Legend

In the heart of Midwood, Brooklyn, Di Fara Pizza stands as a culinary institution, dating back to 1965. Renowned as one of the best pizza restaurants in NYC, Di Fara boasts a honoured tradition of crafting each pizza with care and precision. Dom DeMarco, the mastermind behind the magic, personally oversaw the creation of these delectable pies (until he passed away in 2022), making every bite a unique experience.


Trendy Toppings in Bushwick

Venture into Bushwick, Brooklyn, and discover Roberta’s, a trendy spot redefining pizza norms. Known for wood-fired pizzas with creative and high-quality toppings, Roberta’s injects innovation into the classic pizza experience. The laid-back, hip vibe adds an extra layer of charm to this top restaurant in New York City.

Patsy’s Pizzeria 

A Slice of Tradition in East Harlem

Established in 1933, Patsy’s Pizzeria in East Harlem, Manhattan, famous for its coal oven pizzas, is a cherished gem among the best pizza restaurants in NYC. Known for its thin-crust pizzas, this classic establishment exudes old-school charm and has been serving up slices of tradition for nearly a century.

Artichoke Basille’s Pizza 

Creative Delights in the East Village

Nestled in the vibrant East Village, Artichoke Basille’s Pizza offers a unique and indulgent pizza experience. Renowned for its creamy artichoke slice, this pizzeria tantalises taste buds with inventive flavours. It has secured its place among the top restaurants in New York City for those seeking a departure from the ordinary.

Grimaldi’s Pizzeria 

A Brooklyn Bridge Icon

With a prime location near the Brooklyn Bridge in DUMBO, Brooklyn, Grimaldi’s Pizzeria is a favourite among pizza enthusiasts. Known for its coal-fired brick oven and classic New York-style pizzas, Grimaldi’s offers a picturesque dining experience along with its mouthwatering pies. It’s a perfect stop for those exploring iconic landmarks and craving top-notch pizza.

John’s of Bleecker Street 

Greenwich Village Tradition

In the heart of Greenwich Village, John’s of Bleecker Street has been serving up delectable pizza since 1929. With a cozy atmosphere and a commitment to quality, John’s offers a unique dining experience. As one of the best pizza places in NYC, it continues to capture the hearts of both locals and visitors alike.

Prince Street Pizza 

SoHo’s Spicy Sensation

For a spicy twist on classic pizza, head to Prince Street Pizza in SoHo. Renowned for its square-shaped Sicilian slices, especially the iconic Spicy Spring slice, this pizzeria adds a kick to the traditional New York pizza experience. With its bold flavours, Prince Street Pizza has secured its place among the top pizza restaurants in NYC.

New York City’s pizza landscape is as diverse as the city itself. Whether you’re savouring a historic slice at Lombardi’s, exploring trendy toppings at Roberta’s, or indulging in the creative delights of Artichoke Basille’s Pizza, each pizzeria on this list contributes to the rich tapestry of flavours that define the best pizza restaurants in NYC. Whether you’re a seasoned local or a first-time visitor, embark on a pizza journey through these restaurants to discover the diverse and mouthwatering world of New York City’s pizza scene.

Where to Stay in New York City?

Here are some of our recommended hotels in New York City that you can choose from – 

Pod Times SquareThe New Yorker, A Wyndham HotelBest Western Plus SoHo Hotel | Paramount Hotel Times SquareWalker Hotel Greenwich Village | Millennium Hilton New York One UN PlazaHampton Inn Manhattan – 35th Street Empire State Building | The Manhattan Hotel at Times Square

Or you can simply enter your dates, and hit the search button in the box below, to search and compare prices for the Best Hotels in New York City, based on your needs.

Top New York City Tours and Activities

New York Bus Tour by BigBusTours | Chinatown and Little Italy Food Tour | Manhattan Architecture Yacht Cruise | New York City One Day Guided Sightseeing Tour | 9/11 Memorial Tour and Museum Ticket

Book the Best New York City Tours and Activities on GetYourGuide

Book the Best New York City Tours and Activities on Viator

Book the Best New York City Tours and Activities on Klook

Don’t forget to Pin this NYC Travel Guide and New York Trip Planner featuring the Best Pizza Places to Eat in NYC, carefully crafted and curated by a travel expert, which will help you in planning for your trip to New York City.

Also, if you like reading the content I create and curate, I will be really thankful if you could take a moment to


Also, if you’re on Facebook, I would love to have you as a part of 

the Eat Travel Live Repeat Travel Community

Subscribe via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to Bucket List Travel Guru and receive notifications of new posts by email.

+ There are no comments

Add yours

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.